Books · The Divine Liturgy

Confirmation

HR HR: Human-written; AI-reviewed
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)

Public Reaffirmation of the Baptismal Confession

Closely related to First Communion is the rite of Confirmation — the Lutheran public reaffirmation of baptismal vows that has traditionally marked the conclusion of catechetical preparation. Confirmation has its own history, its own theological character, and its own practical questions that deserve separate treatment.

What Is Confirmation in Lutheran Theology?

Confirmation in the Lutheran tradition is not a Sacrament. This is the most important point of Lutheran confessional distinction. The Roman Catholic Church teaches Confirmation as one of the seven sacraments — conferring the Holy Spirit on the recipient through the bishop’s anointing and laying on of hands. The Lutheran Reformation rejected this view: the Holy Spirit is given in Baptism, not in a separate post-baptismal rite. Confirmation is the affirmation of what was given in Baptism, not the bestowal of something new.

The Lutheran understanding of Confirmation can be summarized in four points.

First, it is a rite of public confession. The baptized — who, as an infant, was confessed for by parents and sponsors — now confesses for himself the faith into which he was baptized. The renunciations and the Apostles’ Creed that the sponsors spoke at the font are now spoken by the catechumen in his own voice.

Second, it is the conclusion of catechesis. The catechumen has been instructed in Luther’s Small Catechism (typically over a two-year period). The Confirmation rite includes a public examination on the catechism, demonstrating the catechumen’s instruction and the family’s and congregation’s preparation.

Third, it is the blessing of the church on the catechumen’s confession. The pastor lays his hand on the catechumen’s head (or makes the sign of the cross over him) and speaks a blessing — a prayer that the Holy Spirit, given in Baptism, would continue to work in the catechumen’s life. The blessing is not the giving of the Spirit (which was done in Baptism) but the church’s prayer for the Spirit’s continued work.

Fourth, in traditional Lutheran practice, it is the admission to the Lord’s Supper. The confirmand, having demonstrated catechetical preparation, is now welcomed to the altar. As noted in the previous chapter, this connection has been weakened in many modern congregations that have adopted earlier First Communion, but it remains the historic Lutheran pattern.

The Historical Development of Confirmation

The history of Confirmation is complex, involving substantial changes between the patristic, medieval, and Reformation periods.

Patristic Origins

In the patristic Western church, what would become “Confirmation” was initially an integrated part of the baptismal rite. After the actual baptism (the water-and-Word), the bishop or priest performed a consignation — an anointing of the newly baptized with chrism (consecrated oil), with the laying on of hands. The action signified the gift of the Holy Spirit and the sealing of the baptized for life in Christ.

This post-baptismal consignation has continued in the Eastern Orthodox tradition as chrismation, integrated immediately with baptism. The Eastern infant is baptized, chrismated, and communed at a single service. There is no separate “confirmation” rite in the Eastern church — chrismation does the work that the Western church would later divide into a separate rite.

In the Western church, the consignation gradually became detached from baptism. As baptism came to be administered by parish priests (who could not maintain the bishop’s monopoly on the anointing), the Western practice developed: parish priests would baptize, and the bishop would come later — sometimes years later — to “confirm” the baptized by the consignation. The separation of baptism from confirmation was originally a practical matter (the bishop’s travel constraints) but became, in time, a theological distinction.

The Medieval Western Pattern

By the high medieval period, Confirmation had become a separate rite, administered by the bishop, often at the “age of discretion” (around seven) or earlier. The Western theology of Confirmation developed: the rite was understood as conferring a strengthening (Latin confirmare, “to strengthen”) of the grace given at Baptism. The Sacrament of Confirmation was held to bestow the gift of the Holy Spirit in a particular way — strengthening the baptized for the spiritual battle of the Christian life.

The medieval pattern thus emerged: baptism in infancy → confirmation by the bishop at the age of discretion (often combined with First Communion in the same rite or shortly thereafter) → continued Christian life. Confirmation in this pattern was a Sacrament; it conferred grace; it was administered only by the bishop.

Luther and the Reformation Reform

Luther’s engagement with Confirmation was sharply critical of the medieval doctrine. He rejected the notion that Confirmation was a Sacrament — there is no dominical institution of Confirmation in Scripture, and the rite does not bear the marks of a Sacrament (an external sign joined to a divine Word with a promise of grace). The medieval theology of Confirmation as bestowing the Holy Spirit was rejected: the Spirit is given in Baptism, and there is no separate later rite by which He is given again.

What, then, was Confirmation to be? Luther initially seems to have wanted to abolish the rite entirely. But pastoral wisdom prevailed: the church needed some way of marking the transition from childhood to adult participation in the rite, some way of formalizing catechetical preparation, and some way of bringing the baptized to public confession of faith.

The Lutheran Reformation therefore developed a new understanding of Confirmation — not as a Sacrament, but as a rite of public confession. The rite preserved the visible action of the medieval Confirmation (the laying on of hands, the blessing, the gathering of the catechumens before the assembly) but with a transformed theology. The Holy Spirit is not given in Confirmation; the Spirit was given in Baptism. The Confirmation rite is the public reaffirmation of the baptismal gift, the conclusion of catechetical preparation, and the church’s blessing on the catechumen’s confession.

Luther’s Small Catechism (1529) became the standard text of Lutheran catechetical preparation. Johann Bugenhagen and other Lutheran reformers developed the specific Confirmation rite. By the early seventeenth century, Lutheran Confirmation had taken its mature form: catechetical preparation, public examination, the catechumen’s affirmation of baptismal vows, the pastor’s blessing, and admission to the Sacrament of the Altar.

Modern Lutheran Practice

The Lutheran tradition has maintained substantial continuity in Confirmation practice for four centuries. The basic pattern — catechetical preparation, public confession, blessing — has remained constant. The variations have been in the curriculum, the duration of preparation, the age of confirmation, and the relationship to First Communion.

The Confirmation Service Structure

A typical Lutheran Confirmation service follows substantially this pattern. The structure draws on Luther’s reform and has remained substantially stable across the LSB, LBW, ELW, CW, and ELH rites.

  1. Hymn of Invocation, with the catechumens seated in a designated place.

  2. Address to the Catechumens. The pastor speaks a brief address explaining the rite’s significance.

  3. Presentation. The catechumens are presented to the congregation by name, sometimes with biographical information or testimony.

  4. Public Examination. The pastor (or designee) examines the catechumens on the Six Chief Parts of the Small Catechism. This may be done with prepared questions and answers, with extempore questioning, or with a sermon-form examination. The purpose is to demonstrate the catechumens’ understanding to the congregation — not to test them in the moment but to display the catechesis they have received.

  5. Renunciation. Each catechumen renounces “the devil, all his works, and all his ways” — the same threefold renunciation that was spoken by sponsors at infant baptism, now spoken in the catechumen’s own voice.

  6. Confession of Faith. Each catechumen confesses the Apostles’ Creed in question-and-answer form — again, the same Creed that the sponsors spoke at the font.

  7. The Confirmation Itself. The pastor lays his hand on each catechumen’s head (or in some traditions traces the sign of the cross on the catechumen’s forehead) and speaks the Confirmation prayer. Typical wording: “Almighty God in His mercy has given you the new birth of water and the Spirit and has forgiven you all your sins. Strengthen you with His grace to life everlasting. Amen.” The wording emphasizes that the Spirit was already given in Baptism; Confirmation is the prayer that the Spirit’s work would continue.

  8. First Communion (in traditional pattern). The newly confirmed are welcomed to the altar for First Communion at the same service or shortly thereafter.

  9. Blessing and Hymn of Conclusion.

The whole rite is integrated into the Divine Service — typically at a special Sunday of Confirmation (often the Sunday after Easter, in some traditions; Pentecost in others; or another Sunday selected by the congregation). It is a major occasion in the congregation’s life, with families gathered, the congregation present, and substantial preparation visible to all.

Curriculum and Preparation

Lutheran Confirmation preparation has historically used Luther’s Small Catechism as the principal text. The Six Chief Parts provide the structure:

  1. The Ten Commandments — the moral law, with Luther’s explanations of each commandment as “we should fear and love God so that…”

  2. The Apostles’ Creed — the three articles, with Luther’s explanations of each as “I believe that…”

  3. The Lord’s Prayer — the seven petitions, with Luther’s explanations of each.

  4. The Sacrament of Holy Baptism — its nature, its gifts, its use, and the practice of baptismal piety.

  5. Confession (or “The Office of the Keys and Confession”) — the doctrine of absolution, individual and corporate confession.

  6. The Sacrament of the Altar — its nature, its gifts, the proper preparation, and the worthy reception.

Additional elements typically covered:

  • The structure of the Lutheran Confessions
  • Basic church history
  • The Lutheran Reformation
  • Christian morality and the Christian life
  • Vocation and Christian responsibility
  • Prayer and the spiritual life

The curriculum is typically taught over two years — beginning in the autumn of seventh grade and culminating in the spring of eighth or ninth grade. Some congregations use longer or shorter periods. Class sizes vary; some pastors prefer small groups for substantial conversation, others have larger classes.

The Age of Confirmation

The traditional Lutheran age for Confirmation has been thirteen or fourteen — the early teen years. This age has held steady across Lutheran tradition for centuries, even as cultural patterns have shifted around it. The reasons for this age include:

  • Cognitive maturity — the catechumen is old enough to engage with substantial theological material
  • Adolescent identity formation — the catechumen is at the age when religious commitments are taking shape
  • Cultural transition — confirmation has marked the transition from childhood religious life to adult religious life
  • Practical timing — most catechumens are in the seventh-to-ninth grade range, providing a stable cohort for catechetical instruction

Some Lutheran traditions have moved the age earlier or later, but thirteen or fourteen remains the dominant Lutheran age.

Variations Across the Lutheran Bodies

  • LCMS: Traditional pattern with two years of catechesis culminating at age 13–14. Some congregations have introduced longer or shorter preparation; some have moved to a “lifelong confirmation” model with ongoing catechesis after the formal rite.

  • WELS: Traditional pattern. WELS has historically required substantial catechetical preparation (often using “An Explanation of Luther’s Small Catechism,” the WELS supplement to the Small Catechism).

  • ELS: Traditional pattern. Closely parallels WELS practice.

  • ELCA: More variable. Some ELCA congregations preserve the traditional pattern; others have moved Confirmation to later ages (sometimes high school) or to a more flexible model. ELCA has generally moved First Communion to a younger age, so Confirmation in ELCA is more clearly a separate affirmation rite rather than admission to the Sacrament.

Pastoral and Theological Considerations

Several pastoral and theological considerations attend modern Confirmation practice.

The Catechetical Question. The depth of Confirmation preparation varies significantly across congregations. Some congregations maintain rigorous catechesis; others have allowed the program to become routine or superficial. The pastoral wisdom is that Confirmation is only as valuable as the catechetical preparation that precedes it. A confirmation class that has not actually engaged with the Small Catechism and the substance of the faith produces confirmands who can recite words without understanding what they confess.

The Generational Question. In an era when biblical and theological literacy has declined in much of the broader American culture, confirmation catechesis carries weight it did not always need to bear. The catechumen may be encountering substantial Christian teaching for the first time in his life through the confirmation program. The pastor’s task is therefore more demanding than it once was — the catechumen may not have the family background of casual Christian conversation that previous generations brought to the catechetical encounter.

The “Graduation” Misconception. A common pastoral concern is that some catechumens (and their families) treat Confirmation as a kind of religious “graduation” — the end of religious instruction rather than the beginning of adult participation. The pastoral response is to teach explicitly against this misconception: Confirmation is the beginning of mature catechetical engagement, not the end. The confirmed adult should continue to study the Small Catechism throughout life; Luther himself reread it daily.

The Relationship to First Communion. As discussed in the previous chapter, modern Lutheran practice has weakened the historic connection between Confirmation and First Communion. In congregations that have moved First Communion earlier, Confirmation is no longer the admission to the Sacrament. This change has both pros and cons. The pro: the rite of Confirmation is more clearly recognized as a rite of public confession, not as a “graduation to communion.” The con: the practical connection between catechetical preparation and admission to the Sacrament is weakened, and catechumens may take Confirmation less seriously without the immediate prospect of First Communion attached to it.

A Final Reflection

Confirmation in the Lutheran tradition has been one of the great gifts of the Reformation. Luther’s catechetical project — making substantial Christian teaching available to every member of the church, in the vernacular, with substantial repetition and depth — produced generations of Lutherans who knew their faith. The Small Catechism has been one of the most influential Christian texts ever written, taught to children in homes and schools and parishes across centuries and continents.

The contemporary pastoral challenge is to preserve and renew this catechetical heritage. The teenager who memorizes Luther’s explanations of the Commandments and Creed; who learns the Lord’s Prayer with Luther’s careful petition-by-petition exposition; who studies the Sacraments and the Office of the Keys; who confesses publicly at Confirmation what was confessed for him at the font — this teenager is being given a treasure that will sustain him through the years to come. The challenge is to maintain the depth of catechetical preparation against the pressure of contemporary culture to make it shallow.

Where Lutheran Confirmation is done well — with substantial catechetical preparation, with patient teaching by the pastor, with engaged families, with serious examination, with appropriate liturgical weight — it produces confirmands who can say, at the rite and through their lives: “I know who I am. I am baptized; I have been taught the faith; I confess it as my own.” This is the gift of Lutheran Confirmation — and the gift, more deeply, of the catechetical Lutheran tradition that produced it.

Topics
BaptismThe Lord's SupperThe Holy Spirit
Confessions
SC

© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.

Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.