Why Denominations Exist
Assisted by: Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic)
If Christ prayed for unity and the apostles wrote for unity, why is the visible Church divided? There is no single explanation that does justice to the whole picture. Denominationalism has theological, historical, cultural, organizational, moral, and anthropological causes.
First and most important, sincere Christians have disagreed about what Scripture teaches. Christians have not divided mainly because they were foolish or wicked (though those things have played their part). They have divided because they disagreed in conscience about the Word of God. Does Baptism actually give the forgiveness of sins, or is it a sign of a forgiveness already received? Is the bread of the Lord’s Supper truly the body of Christ, or a memorial of His death, or a true but spiritual feeding on Christ by faith, given with the bread while His body remains in heaven? Is the local congregation independent under Christ alone, or gathered into a larger body under bishops or elders or synods? Is a sinner justified by faith alone, or by faith working through love? These questions concern how God saves sinners and how He gathers the saved into His Church, and Christians have divided over them because they decided they could not in conscience confess what the other side was confessing.
That charity matters. The man who followed Zwingli in Zurich or Calvin in Geneva was not, as a rule, an opportunist. He had read the same Bible and reached different conclusions. The Puritan who left England for Massachusetts to gather a congregation of visible saints was not, as a rule, a fanatic. However, to grant that Christians of other churches have acted in good conscience is not to grant that they have been correct. Where two churches teach contradictory things about the Gospel or the Sacraments, both cannot be right and the Lutheran Confessions do not hesitate to reject teaching that is contrary to Scripture (for instance, AC X).
In addition, the divisions have a long history. The oldest large division of all came long before Wittenberg. The churches of the East and the West drifted apart over the authority of the pope and over the filioque (“and the Son”) that the Western Church added to the Nicene Creed. The break is usually dated to 1054, though it hardened over centuries. In the West, reform movements rose and were suppressed through the later Middle Ages (the Waldensians, John Wycliffe and the Lollards, Jan Hus and the Hussites). When Luther posted the Ninety-Five Theses in 1517, he was bringing to a head a long argument about authority, doctrine, and pastoral practice. The evangelical side of the Reformation did not hold together either. The Anabaptists had already broken with Zwingli in Zurich by 1525, and Luther and Zwingli failed to agree on the Lord’s Supper at Marburg in 1529. England broke from Rome by an act of Parliament in 1534, a break that began in royal politics as much as in reform and that later took its own Protestant shape. The English Baptists (with John Smyth, 1609) came out of English Separatism and are distinct from the continental Anabaptists. John Wesley never meant to found a church either. Methodism began as a renewal movement within the Church of England, and Wesley died an Anglican priest in 1791. American Methodists became a separate body in 1784, after the Revolution left them without clergy to give them the Sacraments. By 1700 the map of European Christianity was a patchwork and the politics of Europe and the theology of its churches had each shaped the other.
Likewise, the Gospel takes root in particular cultures. Americans tend to overlook this because we live in one of the most denominationally divided countries on earth and mistake that for normal. Across the world much of the denominational map is really a national map. Lutheranism became the church of much of Germany and of Scandinavia, Anglicanism the church of England, and Presbyterianism the church of Scotland. The Eastern Orthodox are organized into self-governing national churches (Greek, Russian, Serbian, Romanian, and others) that understand themselves as one Church in communion. When immigrants came to America, they brought their churches with them. The Pennsylvania Germans planted Lutheran and Reformed churches, the Scots-Irish Presbyterian churches, the English Episcopal, Methodist, Baptist, and Congregational churches, and the Irish Catholic parishes. Denominations are partly the record of immigration.
Christians have also divided over how the Church should be governed. Should she be led by bishops in apostolic succession, by assemblies of elders, or by the gathered congregation itself? Should pastors be set apart by other pastors, called by their congregations, or both? These are practical questions but they touch on real convictions about the authority Christ has given to His Church, and differences here have been enough to start whole new denominations.
Not every division has been over doctrine. Some denominations exist because one leader quarreled with another and left. Some exist because a congregation could not keep peace within itself and split. Some exist because of pride, ambition, or plain stubbornness. Paul called that kind of rivalry “worldly” (1 Corinthians 3:3–4, NIV), and some divisions in the Church have been, plainly, sin.
Lastly, underneath all of these causes runs a deeper one. Human beings are finite creatures. We “know in part” (1 Corinthians 13:9). We live in particular places at particular times and speak particular languages. We gather, organize, and name ourselves. We are also fallen, and sin darkens even our understanding of spiritual things. The Formula of Concord teaches that the natural man’s reason is blind in spiritual matters apart from the Holy Spirit (FC SD II, 9–12), and even a regenerate Christian does not see everything God sees. However, finitude explains why we disagree; it does not make every answer right. Scripture is clear on the Gospel. Where Christians contradict one another about it, someone is in error and the humble response is not to shrug but to go on searching the Word together. The grief Christ expressed in John 17 over the unity of His people is a grief we ought to share. The divisions exist, in short, because the Church on earth is made up of human beings who are both limited and sinful.
© 2026 Dylan MacDonald. You may copy and share this work for any non-commercial purpose, in print or electronically, provided it is reproduced without alteration and with this notice. All other rights reserved.
Scripture quotations marked NIV are taken from the Holy Bible, New International Version®, NIV®. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.™ Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide.
See permissions for congregational use. Questions or comments? Write to the author.